So last week I had the wonderful opportunity to see my brother and sister-in-law and my sweet little niece when they were visiting from out of province. They live a looooong plane ride away, so I don’t see them often, and it was so good to have the chance. All told we only squeezed in a too-short afternoon of visiting at the museum, but it was still wonderful.
And of course, I got the
chance to give them their quilt. (This would be the quilt I posted about here,
for the Quilt Festival that Park City Girl is hosting) And I must say that it
was perhaps the most rewarding gift giving experience that I have had in a long
time. She literally wept tears of joy (the mama, not the baby) and gushed and
oohed and ahhed over it, and reminisced about all the little pieces of clothing
that were included in the quilt, just as I knew she would, and she said all
sorts of lovely things about how she never could have imagined it being as
beautiful and as perfect as it was.
People, that is how you respond to a hand made gift!
You see, there have been a few posts out in the blogoshpere about giving hand-made gifts and getting lukewarm reactions, (Posts here and here) and wanted to add my two cents. Among crafters, you will always be able to find a story like this: Crafter makes a lovely hand-made item, very time intensive, filled with love and meaning, and presents it to a loved one only to have it sadly under-appreciated if not down-right rejected. Everyone who makes things has one of these stories. So as the Christmas season approaches I wanted to suggest some strategies to take the risk out of hand-made gift giving. I thought this might help.
Guidelines for giving hand made gifts:
1. Ask your intended recipient if they would like a hand made gift: This will make a world of difference. Many people actually don’t want a handmade gift. They think it is a lesser gift (erroneously of course, but that’s what they think) and prefer something shiny and new, purchased at a mall and made by a small child in a third world country. And honestly, isn’t your art making time too precious to waste a hand-made baby quilt on someone who doesn’t want one? Now, I know all this takes away the fun of the 'surprise' gift, but imagine all the grief and time it will save you in the event of the dreaded unwelcome surprise. Plus also, the recipient gets the fun of anticipation as they look forward to their custom designed hand knit socks.
2. Listen carefully to their reply: Sometimes people say yes in order not to hurt your feelings. Or they say yes under duress because you are not so much asking them, but telling them - because you are going to make them this wonderful beautiful thing and then if they don’t say yes, then obviously they don’t love you. Or they say yes, but not very enthusiastically. Really listen to their tone.
3. Involve the recipient in design/material choices: Consult with them. What kind of sweater would they like? What colour? Take them shopping for the materials. Many a hand-knit sits in the closet because the receiver would not wear wool because they think it is scratchy, or because you knit them a cashmere baby sweater and they don’t ever put in on the baby because then they’d have to ‘gasp’ hand wash it! I know there are great arguments for all these objections, and I know that I certainly prefer to knit with high quality natural fibers, but if they say they won’t wear wool, don’t go on about malabrigo, and how you can wear a light long sleeved t-shirt underneath etc. Just don’t knit them a wool sweater.
4. And if all else fails, only give hand made gifts to people who already make things. That’s the bottom line. For example, Ken in accounting will not be able to appreciate that you hand knit him those socks out of merino wool. He will just see socks and think that it’s a pretty crap present. (Like that scene in The Office where Phyllis knits oven mitts for the Christmas gift swap, and then Michael Scott gets them, and is so cruelly unappreciative of them that I nearly cried!) Save yourself the time and money and just get him chocolate or an Amazon gift certificate. Life is short.